The Seven Days’ Battles- Gaines’ Mill and the Breakthrough Trail

The image below is from an American Battlefield Trust sign near the Confederate left flank near the Old Cold Harbor Crossroads provides an overview of the final phase of the battle. With all of his forces on the battlefield Lee would launch his largest assault of the Civil War with an attack on Porter’s Corps across the entire line at 7:00 PM. D.H. Hill and Ewell attacked Sykes on the Confederate left and drove them off the ridge. Longstreet’s attack on the far right was through particularly difficult terrain and withering Union artillery fire. John Bell Hood and Evander Law’s brigades were on Longstreet’s left. Lee met with Hood ordering him forward with instructions that the Union line must be broken.

37.5901472, -77.2707808

Two maps of the attack on this portion of Lee’s right by Longstreet and Whiting’s divisions are shown below (they appear on signs on the battlefield). The attack is interpreted by the “Decisive Moment” sign on the trail below. Hood attacked with the 1st, 4th, and 5th TX, the 18th GA and the Hampton Legion. Law would command the 2nd and 11th MS (a monument to this regiment was shown in the previous post), 4th AL, and 6th NC. They would be opposed by George Morell’s division. Hood and Law’s men charged without firing and broke the first Union defensive line at the bottom of the ridge. As the Federal first line fell back, with the Rebels right behind them, they made it difficult for the second and third lines to fire on the Confederates. As a result, the second and third lines were overrun as well, and 14 artillery pieces were captured at the top of the ridge. In the process Hood and Law’s brigades suffered 1,018 casualties, a quarter of the men engaged. The 4th TX suffered 570 of those casualties including all of their field level officers. Longstreet’s men finally pushed through the swamp on the far right and the Union left collapsed. A counterattack by the 5th US Cavalry to attempt to recover the guns failed. In total Porter lost 22 guns. The Federal line had broken on the left, right, and center and fell back toward the river as darkness ended the battle.

Thomas Meagher’s and William French’s brigades from Sumner’s II Corps crossed the river and provided reinforcements as Porter retreated toward the river providing cover for his withdrawal. The battle was costly for both sides Porter lost 894 killed, 3,114 wounded and 2,829 captured for a total of 6,837 casualties. The Confederates had 1,483 killed, 6,402 wounded, and 108 missing for a total of 7,993 casualties. It would be the costliest battle of the Seven Days. Just before midnight McClellan would meet with his generals and informed them that they would be retreating to the James River.

The signs below are present in the parking lot

37.5741944, -77.2908056 Link
Gaines’ Mill Battlefield Loop Trail Map- brochure

The sign below which was present during my last visit several years ago was missing in July of 2024.

37.5740556, -77.2908611

Looking from the kiosk to the left of the road at the first sign for the Breakthrough Trail in the distance.

Zoom view of previous picture. The walking trail heads into the woods to the right of the sign.
Looking west from the kiosk
Looking further west
Looking south toward the Watt house from the kiosk
37.5739722, -77.2907222 Link Entrenched in three lines on this plateau, the right wing of McClellan’s army, withdrawn from Beaver Dam Creek, resisted Confederate attacks on June 27, 1862 until driven back at nightfall by a general assault.
37.5739444, -77.2906389 Link
The Watt House

The next four pictures were taken from the Watt house of the field to the east.

The first sign on the trail is just outside the woods

37.5746667, -77.2912500 Link
37.5746667, -77.2912500 Link
37.5750556, -77.2920278 Link
Looking down the ridge to the creek and swamp
Boatswain’s Creek
Creek
Looking up the ridge toward an earthwork
Earthwork

A small “The Battles Begins” marker should have been between the two signs but I could not locate it. Almost all of the smaller signs that are listed on the Historical Marker Database on the trail with a few exceptions appear to have been removed.

37.5748056, -77.2939722 Link
The trail is very close to the creek at this point
Boatswain’s Creek
The trail then forks

I initially turned to the left up the hill where the signs below were located.

37.5742222, -77.2932778 Link
37.5740278, -77.2932778 Link

I then retraced my path back down the hill to take the trail to the Alabama Monument and Battlefield Overlook.

37.5745556, -77.2937222 Link
Looking down the ridge from the sign
37.5730000, -77.2960000 Link
37.5730000, -77.2960000

The trail then emerges from the woods and makes a right-hand turn where the Watt Farm Road sign is located.

37.5726944, -77.2941944 Link
Path to the overlook

There is only one sign present at the overlook. The two smaller signs listed as being here in the Historical Marker Database “Cavalry Charge” and “Mistaken Identity” were not present.

37.5714722, -77.2950833 Link
View from the overlook
View from the overlook

I then retraced my steps back along the fence to the parking lot. The small signs “Union Artillery”, “Federals Collapse” and “Confederate Pursuit” listed in the Historical Marker Database were not present on the walk back to the parking lot.

37.5735556, -77.2923611 Link
37.5738889, -77.2912778 Link

This completed the Battlefield Loop Trail. The remainder of the signs shown below are to the east on the way to and south of the Old Cold Harbor crossroads.

37.5858611, -77.2768611- On the Cold Harbor Battlefield
37.5910842, -77.2720425
37.5910842, -77.2720425
37.5901472, -77.2707808 Link
37.5860395, -77.2707064
Looking south
Looking north
37.5815076, -77.2709881
Looking north from the marker

Walking Trails at Gaines Mill. There is also a Confederate Attack Trail (link to brochure) which I have not yet walked. It has posts in the ground but no signs that I am aware of.

Map of walking trails

Next- Garnett’s and Golding’s (Gouldins) Farm

Source

Richmond Shall Not Be Taken The Seven Days’ Battles June 25- July 1, 1862 by Doug Crenshaw