Lieutenant Colonel George R. Maxwell and the Solitude Mill

In the final year of the war the economy in the south had collapsed and inflation was rampant. Although the war had largely bypassed Fluvanna County that was about to end. Phil Sheridan’s Army of the Shenandoah was coming their way. His men had left Winchester on February 27th with 5 days of rations in their knapsacks and today was March 6th. They had been liberally foraging off the land and the homes in their path. A 300-man contingent of the 1st Michigan Cavalry was riding down the main road to Palmyra, which paralleled modern-day Route 53 passing right by Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello. His orders from the Official Records are shown below.

Official Records, Chapter 53, page 486

Maxwell was ordered to follow the path of the Fluvanna River. If he were traveling today from Charlottesville he would travel on Virginia Route 53 (Thomas Jefferson Parkway) past Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello. During the Civil War the road system in that area is shown below. A route similar to Route 53 is illustrated in red. There is no equivalent to Route 53 between the Albemarle/Fluvanna County line and Cunningham. The 300-man column if they traveled this route would have needed to travel on smaller farm roads for about 5.5 miles as the crow flies.

The Spring 1993 Fluvanna County Historical Society Bulletin republished a memoir of Sergeant B. J. Haden from Fluvanna County, a member of the 1st Virginia Cavalry, that was first published in 1912. Haden was on leave and was at his Uncle’s house the day the 1st MI came through Palmyra. On page 38 it states, “It was this winter of ‘64 or the spring of ‘65 that Sheridan made his raid up the Valley, crossing the mountain at Rockfish Gap, passing through Charlottesville, and then through Fluvanna, burning Buckeyeland factory, the bridge across the river, mill at Palmyra, and committing depredations too numerous to mention.” Buckeyeland during the war was Buck Island, which was in Albemarle County, shown on the map below. The Buck Island Factory, marked by the red box, was on the west side of the Rivanna River just south of the point where Buck Island Creek empties into the river. I can find no other mention of this particular factory during the war. I did find an article in Charlottesville Tomorrow that mentions it. The factory was located on the Garland Farm, which was unusual in that it was a Black-owned farm during the war. It was written by Philip Cobbs who grew up on the farm. He states that as a child, “I floated the Rivanna River and saw remnants of dams and locks. I remember seeing a millstone next to the river, the only thing left from a mill that once stood on my family’s farm, noted on old maps as “Garland Factory.” If Haden’s statement is true this would strongly suggest the Federals traveled along the general path of modern-day VA-53.

Another possibility was that they traveled over larger more well known roads, shown in the maps below. Coming from Charlottesville that would be the Three Chopt Road (Richmond Road) to the Stage Coach Road (modern-day Union Mills Road) through Union Mills to what is labeled in the map below as the Court House Road (modern-day Virginia Route 15- James Madison Highway) to Palmyra. The later route is clearly visible on Gilmer’s 1863 map. Which of these routes they actually traveled is unknown.

Fluvanna Historical Society Bulletin Volume 12
Route on Gilmer’s 1863 map

The column was led by Lieutenant Colonel George R Maxwell and below are 2 reports from his superior officers about what he destroyed in Palmyra. They were not present with Lieutenant Colonel Maxwell so they must have relied on his verbal report to them to file their written reports. Maxwell did not file a report of his own. The thing that seems odd about the report is the large amount of cotton destroyed. Cotton wasn’t a major crop in the Palmyra area. He did destroy the covered bridge and the Palmyra Mill on the Rivanna River.

Official Records, Chapter 53, Page 490 Devin’s report
Official Records, Chapter 53, Page 495- Stagg’s report
Sketch of the Palmyra Mill – Old Jail Museum
Diorama of the Covered Bridge in the Old Jail Museum

Two of the three stone supports of the covered bridge are still present one in the middle of the river, and another on dry ground beyond the bank of the river, shown below. The pictures were taken in September. I will return in February to reshoot them.

The support rises from a stone island in the middle of the river
Closer view of the support in the middle of the river
This support is set back slightly above the bank of the river on dry ground

After his men finished their destruction on the east side of the river the 1st MI headed toward Scottsville. They would have passed right by the structure below, the Solitude Mill, but yet they didn’t destroy it!

The Solitude Mill
George R Maxwell

The officers and men from the Ml Cavalry regiments were members of hard fighting elite cavalry units. Their officers believed in leading from the front. Local lore has it that women from the town pleaded that the Solitude Mill was the only mill left in the area and that they would starve if it were destroyed (Charlottesville Daily Progress, April 10, 1956- see sources at the end of the post). It seems likely that they would have made their pleas to the front of the column as the Federals were riding south toward Scottsville after finishing their destruction in town. In the end the decision would have belonged to the commanding officer and/or members of his staff. Maxwell would have been only 22 years old at the time. He was born on September 16, 1842, in Monroe, Michigan and had enlisted in Company K of the 1st MI Cavalry as a corporal at age 19 on August 15, 1861. By early 1862 he was a sergeant in the same company. He was commissioned a First Lieutenant on July 30, 1862, and transferred to Company E. The following year he was promoted to captain on August 22, 1863, and Lieutenant Colonel on October 25, 1864. He was captured at Second Bull Run on August 31, 1862. At Brentsville, VA, on December 31, 1862, while leading a small 6-man scouting patrol, his unit was ambushed by Confederate “Iron Scouts”. During a brief street fight that followed he was wounded in the right shoulder. He served at the battles of Cedar Mountain, Second Bull Run, Gettysburg, Monterey Pass, the Wilderness, Yellow Tavern, Haw’s Shop, Cold Harbor and Trevilian Station. He was wounded multiple times during the war. He lost the tips of the index, middle and ring fingers of his left hand from a sabre wound at Gettysburg. At Monterey Pass he was wounded in the left knee. At Haws Shop he was wounded in the left forearm and lost several inches of bone. He was sent to the General Hospital in Georgetown where he underwent three operations and was left with a draining wound in the arm. Unable to use the arm he rode his horse into battle with the reins in his mouth with a sabre or revolver in his right hand. He was awarded the Custer Medal given only to the most deserving officers of the Michigan Brigade.

Sheridan and his men were not known for their generosity in sparing any infrastructure that could possibly aid or support the Confederate cause but for some reason they made an exception at the Solitude Mill that day. Perhaps it was due to the women and children’s pleas for mercy, but Lieutenant Colonel Maxwell and his men spared the mill and rode on to Scottsville, see possible routes in the appendix.

Ward K Armory Square Hospital- LOC

Less than a month later Maxwell would be in a desperate fight for his own life. At the Battle of Five Forks on April 1, 1865, he was shot in the left leg by a Minié ball. The bullet entered opposite the head of the fibula and opened the knee joint. His case was described in The Medical and Surgical History of the War of the Rebellion. (1861-65.), Part 3, Volume 2, page 278. “CASE 459.—Lieutenant-Colonel George R. Maxwell, 1st Michigan Cavalry, aged 22 years, was wounded at Five Forks, Virginia, April 1, 1865. He was taken to the field hospital of the Cavalry Corps and remained there until April 15th, when he was sent to Washington on the hospital steamer Connecticut, and admitted to the Armory Square Hospital on the 16th. Acting Assistant Surgeon C. A. Leale, in a special report of the case, furnishes the following particulars: “The left knee joint was opened by a conoidal ball, which had entered opposite the head of the fibula and was extracted at point of entrance. He was very anæmic and in a generally unfavorable condition; extensive suppuration had taken place, the leg had become infiltrated with serum, the knee joint was filled with pus, and the muscles of the thigh had been separated by extensive abscesses extending as high as the apex of Scarpa’s triangle. April 17th, no change in his condition; he was placed under the influence of ether, and the thigh amputated by the circular operation, at the middle third, by Surgeon D. W. Bliss, U. S. V.; the stump was dressed with water, and the patient placed in bed. April 18th, although twelve ligatures had been applied, hæmorrhage continued to take place (he being apparently of a hæmorrhagic diathesis), and altogether about eight ounces of blood was lost. Applied liquor ferri persulphas by a camel’s hair brush to the whole of the surface of the wound, which had been left open and exposed to the air for about fifteen minutes; this, with the styptic, entirely checked all oozing. April 20th, the granulations had become healthy; about two drachms of pus discharged daily. On the 30th the stump had nearly closed. June 23d, a piece of necrosed femur of a conical shape, and about four inches in length, was removed. August 8th, he was mustered out of service; his stump (FIG. 192) was solid and in good condition.” The pensioner was paid June 4, 1879.” Shown below are pictures of Lieutenant Colonel Maxwell, and a sketch of his stump postoperatively.

George Maxwell was a lucky man. He survived a mid-thigh wound that required amputation. His amputation occurred beyond the 48-hour window associated with better outcomes and carried on average a 73% mortality. In his case it would have been even higher given three negative prognostic factors- the severity of his infection, postoperative bleeding, and the need for a second surgery. The only thing in his favor in an era where antibiotics had yet to be discovered was his young age. He would survive the war just like the mill he spared. On April 18th he was promoted to Brevet Colonel for conspicuous gallantry and mustered out of the army on August 4, 1865.

Appendix- the Case Report

Other Sources

Gettysburg to Great Salt Lake, George R. Maxwell Civil War Hero and Federal Marshal among the Mormons by John Gary Maxwell

Appendix– additional images

Buck Island Creek crossing the Thomas Jefferson Parkway VA-53 (Albemarle County)- 379584299, -78.3895053

Buck Island Creek flowing toward the Rivanna River

The intersection of Garland Lane with the Thomas Jefferson Parkway appears to be near the area on wartime maps where the Buck Island Church was located- 37.953378, -78.3807963

Standing on Garland Lane looking north, Thomas Jefferson Parkway to the right
Looking up Garland Lane

Possible routes to Scottsville

The Haden Martin Road would be the shortest route. The Central Plains Road is about 2 miles further south. Raccoon Creek would be between these two roads. So, if they did take the Central Plains Road, they would need to ford Raccoon Creek

The column would have headed south on modern day VA-15. This part of the road in 1863 was the Cocke Road. They would then have headed southwest on either the Haden-Martin Road or the Central Plains Road (both were wartime roads) to the River Road. When heading south on the Cocke Road they would have first encountered the Haden-Martin Road.
Modern satellite map

The modern-day intersection corresponding to the Cocke Road (James Madison Highway) and Haden Martin Road- 37.8490689, -78.2718946

The 1st MI would have been coming toward the camera
Haden Martin Road- the 1st MI would be moving away from the camera toward the River Road

The intersection of the Haden Martin Road and the River Road- 37.8039621, -78.3367869

The 1st MI would have been moving toward the camera
The River Road headed west to Scottville- the 1st MI would be moving away from the camera

The modern-day intersection of the Cocke Road (James Madison Turnpike) and the Central Plains Road- 37.8282444, -78.2720991

The 1st MI if they came this way would be moving toward the camers
The 1st MI if they came this way would be moving away from the camera down Central Plains Road toward the River Road

The intersection of Central Plains Road and River Road- 37.8048167, -78.3261365

The 1st MI if they came this way would be coming toward the camera
The 1st MI if they came this way would be moving away from the camera west toward Scottsville

The town of Central Plains was located here

Leave a message and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible.