
As Sheridan’s destruction of the canal system in Nelson and Albemarle Counties in Virginia was coming to a close Colonel Charles Fitzhugh’s Brigade was sent east to Columbia in Fluvanna County in preparation for the next phase of the operation. They made a forced march of fifty-six miles in seventeen hours in a heavy rain storm on extremely muddy roads arriving on March 9th. From Columbia Sheridan planned to turn away from the James River and focus his attention on destroying the Virginia Central Railroad. Here Major General Wesley Merritt issued Field Order #7 ordering the commanding officer of the Third Division (David Gregg) to send strong scouting parties on all roads leading in from the left flank (north) to go as far as the Chopped Road (the Richmond Road- modern day VA-250). Colonel Fitzhugh sent out two parties on the morning of the 10th each made up of about 20 men. The first headed toward the Richmond Road and encountered Rebel pickets about fourteen miles out. They charged and captured four men (a private in 4th Virginia Cavalry, two artillerymen, and a farmer). Their most likely route during the war would have taken them from Columbia through Fife to the Haydensville-Fife Road, which intersects the Three Chopped Road (Richmond Road) at Haydensville. Haydensville is about 14 miles from Columbia.
The second party was commanded by Lieutenant Harrison H. Mitchell of Company G of the 6th NY Cavalry. They left Columbia on the Stage Coach Road (modern day Stage Junction Road) toward Wilmington, shown below. The images below were taken from 37.8492489, -78.2015919.


Images from the junction of two antebellum buildings are shown below- Cullin’s Tavern on the left and Cole’s Tavern on the right.


Here, 4 miles from Palmyra, they headed west. On the maps below they would have taken Woodson’s Road (modern day Old Courthouse Road). Fitzhugh’s report states “The party on Palmyra road went a mile beyond Wilmington; met their picket line half a mile this side of town, and drove them through town and one mile beyond, together with some thirty soldiers loafing about the place. They were reenforced from up the road, and the scouting party came back. The Rebel Colonel Nelson is collecting the country people at Palmyra, but Lieutenant Mitchell, commanding the party, thinks there is no organized party there or in the vicinity. The men he met and skirmished with he thinks were not regular soldiers, but farmers, deserters, etc.”


If the Federals met Confederate pickets a half mile east of Palmyra, they would have been three and a half miles from Wilmington near the intersection of Old Courthouse House Road and Georges Mill Road. This would have been the area of Edgewood (132 Georges Mill Road), the home of Headmaster David S. Farrar who owned and operated the Fluvanna Military Institute on the property (Fluvanna Historical Society Bulletin #93 page 15).

Pictures from the intersection of the Old Courthouse and Georges Mill Roads are shown below. The first two pictures were taken looking east toward Wilmington. The 6th NY scouting party would have been moving toward the camera. The images were taken from 37.8610828, -78.2545578.


The Confederates would have fled down the hill shown below back to the town of Palmyra about half a mile away.


Fitzhugh’s report makes no mention of casualties. In an article published in Fluvanna History, part of which appears in the sources, it states “Mitchell cited no casualties during the Palmyra engagement. To the contrary, a postwar report filed by Maj. David W. Anderson of the 44th Virginia Infantry and his nephew, John G. Anderson, adjutant of the same regiment, stated that a veteran of the 44th, Harry Belvin, was killed on March 10 during a skirmish at the county seat. However, this soldier seems to exist only in this report. No one with the name “Belvin,” or with a similar surname, is found in Fluvanna County records, on the infantry’s roster, or the Compiled Service Records maintained by the National Archives.” It goes on to state “Some have speculated that the Andersons’ report indicates that there was another skirmish at Palmyra not necessarily related to the one recorded by Mitchell. The lack of records prevents an answer, or if it did occur who might have resisted the enemy. In 1862 the Virginia General Assembly had authorized localities to raise a militia referred to as “Home Guards” for the defense of local communities. In the county a handful of provisional units known as the Local Defense Troops organized, but it is not known which if any were in operation in March 1865. That winter the Confederate army sent home a significant number of soldiers to conserve provisions. Such a furlough might explain the presence in Fluvanna of soldiers from the 44th Infantry, but any participation by them in a skirmish would have been due to happenstance not organization.”
I visited the Fluvanna Historical Society on several occasions to explore the story of Harry Belvin further. The article below in Major Anderson’s folder at the society refers to a roster that Major Anderson prepared after the war of Company K of the 44th Virgina Infantry donated to the society by Mrs. Beatrice Thomas at the time of the Civil War Centennial observance between 1961 and 1965.

The roster consisted of two pages of men who joined the company at the start of the war listed in alphabetical order and a third page that contained a list of men that were added during the war. Shown below is a list of those that joined at the start, last names A-J. Of note there was no one named Harry Belvin in the initial roster.


Shown below is the roster of those added during the war, which does contain Harry Belvin (red arrow), and it notes that he was a recruit and was wounded at Payne’s Farm (Battle of Payne’s Farm- November 27, 1863). It also states that he was supposed to have been killed near Palmyra. The only skirmish fought near Palmyra during the war was during Sheridan’s Raid on March 10, 1865, discussed above. Anderson was not in Palmyra during the skirmish but must have considered the source reliable enough to include in his roster.

The evidence that Major Anderson was likely not in Palmyra on May 10, 1865, comes from the record shown below. He was discharged from the Charlottesville General Hospital only 5 weeks before. The record stated that he was discharged back to duty. The 44th Virginia would have been involved in the Siege of Petersburg at that time.

Additional evidence for the existence of Harry Belvin in Company K of the 44th VA was found by searching the digitized records of Fold3. A search for Henry or Harry Belvin yielded no results. However, sometimes soldiers only went by their initials during the war and the results of a search for H Belvin are shown below.

Looking through H Belvin and H T Belvin reveals they are probably the same person, there is only one record for each. They are receipt rolls from the Quartermaster’s Bureau for clothing.


In order to interpret the meaning of the receipt rolls forms one needs to understand the regulations governing them. Particularly the meaning of the completion of the signature line on the receipt roll. For that we need to examine the relevant Confederate Army regulations published in- “Regulations of the Army of the Confederate States, 1862, containing a complete set of forms for quartermaster’s, subsistence, ordinance, and medical departments of the Army; articles of war; forms also for general, regimental and garrison courts martial. Published by authority of Gen. P.O. Herbert by Major W.T. Mechling” (link). The part relevant to clothing distribution by the Confederate quartermaster’s department is shown below in the next three images. The fourth image highlights the regulation relevant to the receipt roll form.



The most important regulation #1011 from page 80, shown below, provides instructions for preparation of the receipt roll form. Per the regulation the completion of the signature line indicates that on March 31st, 1864, Private H T Belvin of Company K, 44th Virginia, received an item of clothing and his receipt of the clothing was “witnessed by an officer or non-commisioned officer; the witness to be witness to the fact of the issue and the acknowledgement and signature of the soldier.”

This indicates that there was an H T Belvin present in Company K, 44th Virginia on that date and he appeared in person to collect the item of clothing and that event was witnessed. The lack of a signature on the April 24, 1864, form would indicate that he did not appear in person to collect the item. There could be many reasons for this including among others that he was sick in a local field hospital, or he was on distant picket duty. This time period, March and April of 1864, would have been while Company K of the 44th VA was in winter camp near Clark’s Mountain prior to the start of the Overland Campaign. Company K, the Fluvanna Guards, was commanded by Major David W. Anderson. This is almost certainly the Harry Belvin referred to by Major Anderson who was thought to have been killed near Palmyra.
I next investigated whether there was any other roster of the 44th VA with Harry Belvin’s name in it other than Major Anderson’s list. For this I turned to the Library of Virginia, which has the resources below for Confederate soldiers from Virginia (link)



The library also has available data from the Department of Confederate Military Records. These were records compiled after the war by the state in an attempt to reassemble the rosters of all Virginia units during the Civil War. The history of this project is covered in the link. “On March 13, 1884, the General Assembly passed an act directing the adjutant general to compile a roster of all those who served from Virginia in the Confederate armed forces. The project did not begin, however, until Congress’ passage of an act in 1903 providing for the assembling of muster rolls for all the Confederate states and Virginia’s subsequent creation of the Office of the Secretary of Virginia Military Records in 1904. The work of the Secretary of Virginia Military Records of assembling muster rolls and other documents related to Virginians in the Civil War was continued by the Department of Confederate Military Records which was formed by an act of the General Assemply on March 12, 1912. Major Robert W. Hunter served as Secretary of Virginia Military Records from 1904 until 1910. Hunter was replaced by Colonel Joseph V. Bidgood who served as Secretary of Virginia Military Records and later Secretary of the Department of Confederate Military Records. In 1918, the General Assembly passed an act abolishing the Department of Confederate Military Records and transferred the department’s records to the Library of Virginia.”



The Confederate Rosters Index can be searched online

Search instructions


Searching for the 44th and Belvin leads to one result. Harry Belvin is listed in the 44th Virginia roster in the library. On my next Richmond trip I need to stop here.


The index entry



There is another strange facet to this story. When the 44th VA broke camp at the start of the Overland Campaign they participated in the Battle of the Wilderness (May 5-6, 1864). Shortly thereafter at the Bloody Angle during the Battle of Spotsylvania Courthouse virtually the entire 44th VA regiment was either killed or captured and sent to prison camps for the duration of the war. Either Harry Belvin somehow avoided capture or he wasn’t there.
Now that we have established that someone named H T or Harry Belvin was a member of Company K of the 44th Virginia, who was he really and what would he have been doing in Palmyra on March 10, 1865? According to Colonel Fitzhugh Union Lieutenant Mitchell, commanding the scouting party, felt that “there is no organized party there or in the vicinity. The men he met and skirmished with he thinks were not regular soldiers, but farmers, deserters, etc.”
In the mid 1800s in the state of Virginia the vast majority of Belvins in the state lived in the Tidewater region in Gloucester or York counties. There is no one named Belvin listed in the 19th century censuses living in Fluvanna County. Harry Belvin was not from Fluvanna County. Harry was a common nickname for Henry in the 1800s.
There was a Henry Belvin living in the Tidewater region of an appropriate age for military service who appeared in the 1850 census in Gloucester County and not thereafter. He was a 19-year old oysterman living with his mother Grace who was 40 in the 1850 census. He had 2 younger siblings- Martha A., age 17, and Benjamin age 12, shown below. This person, however, appears to be William Henry Belvin of the 21st Regiment Virginia Militia who appeared in the 1860 and 1870 census in Gloucester County. There is a Benjamin Belvin in the same regiment. In a postwar census William Henry Belvin is living in the same household with a woman named Gracy, old enough to he his mother, and Benjamin. He is the man referred to as Henry Belvin in the 1850 census. He survived the war.


William Henry Belvin enlisted in Co F, of the 26th VA Infantry on April 20, 1861, at Rowes Store, Gloucester. In March of 1862 he is in Captain William K. Perrin’s Company, 26th VA, Company F. From July 1, 1864 to August 22, 1864, he is sick in Chimborazo Hospital in Richmond. His name is on a clothing receipt there signed on August 23rd (with an x). He was furloughed but did not return. In September and October he was absent without leave through February 1865 at least. It turns out he deserted to Federal lines on December 30, 1864, at Yorktown, and was subsequently released January 5, 1865. He was 5 feet ten inches tall with red hair. He took the oath of amnesty. He deserted along with his brother Benjamin below. There is nothing about these timelines that eliminates him as Harry Belvin. However, he did survive the war.
His brother Benjamin Belvin- Company E, 26th VA Infantry enlisted on May 28, 1861. He deserted on December 18, 1864, and came into Federal lines on December 31. He was five foot nine with blue eyes, and light hair. He also took the oath of allegiance. He was in Chimborazo with diarrhea from September 20-October 14, 1864. He is given clothing there October 12 and is recommended for a 1-week furlough.
I identified several other Belvins from Virginia and elsewhere who served during the war. Two of them died during the conflict, one was in North Carolina in 1865, and the other joined the Union Army from the Point Lookout prison camp. James Belvin, the son of John Perrin Belvin and Maria Jenkins, was born in 1843, and died in 1861. James, a waterman, enlisted on April 20, 1861, at Rowe’s Store into Company F of the 26th Virginia Infantry. He missed a lot of time due to illness with or without disease. One source stated he died on December 30, 1861, likely due to disease. Muster rolls after that time show him as absent. Thomas Belvin, James’ brother, was born between 1830-1833 and died in 1864. In 1860 he was an overseer living with the Edward H. Rowe family. Thomas was listed as a farmer when he enlisted on April 20, 1861, the same day as his brother at Rowe’s Store into Company F of the 26th Virginia Infantry. Thomas was killed on July 30, 1864, at the Crater during the siege of Petersburg. (source Family Tree Searcher Volume 10 #2- Names on the Gloucester Confederate Monument by Robert W. Plummer (link)). H D Belvin- Company D, 7th Regiment Confederate Cavalry, enlisted July 28, 1862, in Columbus, Georgia. He was absent without leave from September 27, 1863, to October 1, 1864. He reappears on the bounty rolls in October, 1864. From February 6-18, 1865, he is in General Hospital #11 in Charlotte, NC. John A Belvin- Co. B, 5th NC Cavalry, 63rd NC Partisan Rangers, taken prisoner at Jacks Shops Virginia, September 22, 1863, and sent to Old Capitol Prison and subsequently Point Lookout, Maryland. He joined the US Army on February 26, 1864.
Since Major Anderson reported that Harry Belvin was wounded at Payne’s Farm I searched for anyone with the last name of Belvin reported wounded in that battle in Fold3. The only result was for a Thomas H Belvin of the 3rd NC. He suffered several wounds during the war at Chancellorsville on May 3, 1863, at Payne’s Farm on December 27, 1863, and at Winchester on September 19, 1864. After the Payne’ Farm wound he was hospitalized in Richmond. From March 18 until April 18, 1864, he was again hospitalized in Richmond for bronchitis. This would have overlapped with the date Harry Belvin picked up clothing on March 31st. On December 13, 1864, he was granted a 60-day furlough and there are no further Civil War records for him. He appeared in the 1880 census living in Wake County where he was born with a wife and three children. This doesn’t appear to be Harry Belvin of the 44th VA.
Others named Belvin that I have not yet ruled out are listed below.
William H Belvin- Co. K, 34th VA, Captain R Bagby’s Company B, 4th Regiment of Artillery- listed on the muster role in February of 1862. He was from Gloucester. In March and April of 1862 he was listed as a deserter.
James Belvin- Co E, 26th VA Infantry, enlisted May 28, 1861, at Rowes Store. In January and February of 1862, he was at home by permission. On May 6, 1862, he deserted at King and Queen CH.
W B Belvin- Co F, 26th VA Infantry, no further information.
WA Belvin- Co G, 5th NC Cavalry, 1863-1865, Henderson NC, listed primarily as having no horse.
Andrew C Belvin- Co. F, 7th GA no further information.
The determination that there was indeed a Henry Belvin in the 44th VA has in some ways raised more questions than it has answered. Was he from Virginia at all? When he joined the 44th VA prior to the Battle of Payne’s Farm did he do so under an assumed name (perhaps he was underage or a previous deserter), after all there were no forms of identification during the war? I was hoping that finding that he was in fact a member of the 44th VA would lead to finding a man named Harry or Henry Belvin in the 1850 or 1860 census who then disappears from future censuses and/or had a newspaper death notice. History, however, isn’t always so simple. The comments section is open if anyone has further thoughts.
Sources
Fluvanna History War and Reconstruction 1865-1870, Days of Great Anxiety and Excitement: Sheridan’s Raid into Fluvanna County, March 6-12, 1865 by John C. Settle, Fluvanna Historical Society 2019




Official Records War of the Rebellion Chapter LVIII, pages 919-920

